You will not be allowed to compare more than 4 products at a time
View compareOur peanut butter category features a wide selection of products, including creamy, crunchy, and flavored varieties from trusted brands like Jif, Skippy, and Adams. Ideal for nut butter lovers seeking healthy snacks or meal ingredients, our range includes organic and non-GMO options. Shop here for our quality guarantee and enjoy fast shipping on your favorite spreads.
Showing 1-16 of 1223 Results
-
Sold outSold out
GRANUTS Cranberry Trail Mix - Caramelized Peanuts, Crunchy Corn Nuts
Regular price $76.20Sale price $76.20 Regular priceUnit price / per$108.86Sold out -
Sold outSold out
malt-inspired NUTS Original Peanuts - Sweet and Salty - 3
Regular price $40.78Sale price $40.78 Regular priceUnit price / per$58.26Sold out -
Sold outSold out
Hampton Farms Fancy Roasted In-Shell Unsalted Peanuts, 5 lb Bag
Regular price $36.83Sale price $36.83 Regular priceUnit price / per$52.61Sold out -
Sold outSold out
PLANTERS Chipotle Peanuts, 6 Ounce Bags, Pack of 8, Great
Regular price $22.36Sale price $22.36 Regular priceUnit price / per$31.94Sold out -
Sold outSold out
SKIPPY Natural Super Chunk Peanut Butter Spread, 15 Ounce, Pack
Regular price $51.18Sale price $51.18 Regular priceUnit price / per$73.11Sold out -
Sold outSold out
Jif Natural Squeeze Creamy Peanut Butter, Smooth Texture, 13 Ounce
Regular price $74.83Sale price $74.83 Regular priceUnit price / per$106.90Sold out -
Sold outSold out
PLANTERS Honey Roasted Peanuts, Plant-Based Protein, 34.5 Oz (2 Tubs)
Regular price $29.58Sale price $29.58 Regular priceUnit price / per$42.26Sold out -
Sold outSold out
malt-inspired NUTS Original Sweet and Salty Peanuts, 41 oz Jar,
Regular price $43.93Sale price $43.93 Regular priceUnit price / per$62.76Sold out -
Sold outSold out
Crazy Richards Creamy Vegan Peanut Butter, 100% All-Natural, No Added
Regular price $21.04Sale price $21.04 Regular priceUnit price / per$30.06Sold out -
Sold outSold out
FERIDIES Extra Large Virginia Peanuts, Dill Pickle Flavor, 18oz Tin
Regular price $31.57Sale price $31.57 Regular priceUnit price / per$45.10Sold out -
Sold outSold out
Betty Lous Organic Powdered Peanut Butter, Gluten Free, Vegan, High
Regular price $17.09Sale price $17.09 Regular priceUnit price / per$24.41Sold out -
Sold outSold out
Belmont Peanuts Gourmet Honey Roasted Peanuts, 25 oz, 8 Simple
Regular price $40.72Sale price $40.72 Regular priceUnit price / per$58.17Sold out -
Sold outSold out
Belmont Peanuts Gourmet Sea Salt & Black Pepper Virginia Peanuts,
Regular price $38.09Sale price $38.09 Regular priceUnit price / per$54.41Sold out -
Sold outSold out
TGF TRULY GOOD FOODS Jumbo Peanuts - Ancho Kimchi Flavor
Regular price $23.12Sale price $23.12 Regular priceUnit price / per$33.03Sold out -
Sold outSold out
Nutic Gourmet Butter Toffee Peanuts - Crunchy Candied Snack -
Regular price $40.76Sale price $40.76 Regular priceUnit price / per$58.23Sold out -
Sold outSold out
The Peanut Shop of Williamsburg Handcooked Virginia Peanuts, Lightly Salted,
Regular price $73.55Sale price $73.55 Regular priceUnit price / per$105.07Sold out
Peanut Butter Overview
Peanut butter is a beloved staple found in kitchens around the world, renowned for its rich flavor and versatility. This category encompasses a variety of peanut butter types, including creamy, crunchy, organic, and flavored options. Ideal for everyone, from health-conscious individuals to families looking for convenient snacks, peanut butter can be enjoyed on toast, in smoothies, or as a dip for fruits and vegetables. Its nutritional profile, including healthy fats and protein, makes it a popular choice for those seeking a satisfying and nutritious food source.
What's in This Collection
In our peanut butter collection, you’ll find products from top brands like Jif, Skippy, and natural choices from Adams and Smucker's. We also offer specialty items like organic peanut butter, which is often non-GMO and free from added sugars, and flavored varieties such as chocolate or honey-infused peanut butter. Sizes range from single-serving packets perfect for on-the-go snacking to larger jars ideal for families or meal prep. Prices typically fall between $5 and $15 depending on the brand and size.
How to Choose
When selecting peanut butter, consider your dietary needs and flavor preferences. For those with allergies, it’s important to look for nut butters that meet safety standards, such as being certified gluten-free or containing no added preservatives. If you prefer a smoother texture, go for creamy peanut butter, while crunchy varieties offer a delightful texture contrast. Additionally, assess the ingredient list; the best peanut butters contain minimal ingredients, usually just peanuts and a pinch of salt. For health-conscious shoppers, organic or natural options are advisable.
Gift Ideas & Occasions
Peanut butter makes an excellent gift for a variety of occasions, such as birthdays, holidays, or housewarming parties. It's a thoughtful choice for food lovers and health enthusiasts alike. Consider pairing a gourmet peanut butter jar with artisan bread or a homemade recipe card for a unique gift set. It's also a fantastic stocking stuffer during the holidays, appealing to both kids and adults who enjoy its delicious taste and versatility in cooking and snacking.
















